|
My daughters 1992 240 had a refrigerant leak. I decided to replace the compressor and drier, and change to R-134.
I flushed the evaporator and condenser with denatured alcohol, and replaced the R-12 orifice with an adjustable orifice.
I installed a new Sanden 7 cylinder compressor.
I installed a new accumulator.
I replaced the low pressure switch, and all O rings.
I vacuumed it for 24 hours.
I mearured the R-134 charge ( 80 % of R-12 charge. )
Results are it doesn’t work. It shuts down on low pressure often enough to prevent proper cooling.
Also it makes strange noises; Like a motorcycle in the distance hauling ass,
And when you turn the car off there is a lot of equalization noise.
I am nearing my wits end. Any thoughts?
|
|
-
|
Nearing the end of the story. I removed the $25.00 Auto Zone variable orifice, which had a tiny amount of grit in it. ( Not the problem ) Replaced it with a $3.00 standard orifice. AC now works like a charm. Blows 49 degree air after car cools down at 85 degree ambient. I am embarrassed to admit that I placed more confidence in a new non standard part than my knowledge of physics.
Lessons learned;
Always keep in mind new part does not mean working part.
I will not use a variable orifice again. They cost 8 times what the standard orifice costs, and the one I installed was factory defective. Probably not that much better than standard orifice.
The American made Sanden 7 cylinder compressor is quiet as a mouse, and as I understand,an improvement over the stock 5 cylinder.
The conversion from R-12 to R-134 works just fine on a 1992.
Thanks for the help guys.
|
|
-
|
When I did a 134 conversion on a '92, the Volvo kit that was available at that time contained a different expansion orifice. Did you replace that?
Other than that, I just replaced what seals I could reach and vacuuming with a cheapie Harbor Freight Venturi pump, charge with 3 cans of 134a and it was still blowing cold when I took the car off the road 5 years later.
|
|
-
|
It is interesting that you put 3 cans=36. oz. of R-134 in the system, and it worked fine. I put 22 to 24 oz. ( 80% of normal R-12 capacity), which I thought was correct. Mine gives the symptoms of low charge.
People who have converted R-12 to R-134, how much R-134 did you add, and how happy were you with the results?
|
|
-
|
Just for comparison, I used 36 oz of R-134 in that failed conversion I attempted 16 years ago, but I'm not sure what the R-12 charge was for that TXV system with no suction accumulator, and high-side receiver/dryer. It was the amount the Volvo retrofit called for after "upgrading" the evaporator in that system. It cooled for a couple weeks before it grenaded, by chance, in front of a Volvo dealership. They quoted $1800 at the time. I cut the belt and drove it home. I was never aware of the 80% guideline.
Also, I still have one of those old Robinaire heated graduated cylinders :)
http://cleanflametrap.com/retrofit.pdf
--
Art Benstein near Baltimore
Grandchildren are God's reward for not killing your own children.
|
|
-
|
Hmmmm... I have read the 80% charge requirement in more than one place, but don't know the theory behind it. That charging cylinder will be easy to sell if you ever wish to.
|
|
-
|
Hi,
How have you come out on getting your A/C to work?
Did you make any conclusions on the amount of charge or if the orifice was the issue?
It won't be long before your conclusions will have to be converted into one of your resolutions!
Be it a new year and all, one needs to lay plans to make them Happy ones, since 2017, didn't fair you well in the A/C department.
I wish you a Happier New Year!
Phil
|
|
-
|
More head scratching;
During this job, I used 12 oz. of R-134 with dye. I checked for a leak with the yellow glasses in complete darkness and found nothing.
Today it is 65 or 70 degrees. I turned the AC on, drove for 15 minutes.
No AC. raised the hood. Compressor not running, LP switch open. I bypassed the ( brand new) LP switch for 60 seconds. when I removed the jumper, the AC continued to run for 10 minutes!!! Gremlins. I am not through this yet.
|
|
-
|
Hi,
Sounds like the low side pumped down and caused the new switch to open and consequently no cooling.
You got out to see no compressor running. Under this condition that is correct.
You jumped the LP to make it run again and it did. Did it get cooler?
Now you took the jumper off and because you left the snow flake switch on, the delay relay must have turned on and called for cooling. Could be a problem with that relay and also not?
I don’t care for those things. On my 1986 I jumpered around it like the LP switch. It won’t hurt anything.
The next thing was the low side got pumped down! This would point to a restriction.
Since you ran the compressor long enough and hard enough you may have temporarily sucked the restriction through.
Since it ran ten minutes did it get any colder? Frost or sweating any place along the lines on the high side. The low side should get colder including the accumulator.
I keep thinking there is a oil blockage coming through hopefully!
The next thing could be a bursted desiccant bag as these things can age. This would be a pain.
Without knowing the pressures on both sides we are stuck with playing in a hay stack.
I hate these systems that cheap out on valves or ports.
When you cleaned the system did you ever see stuff like black grit on the condenser side or in the old orifice screens?
If so, you may have to clean the system again and replace the accumulator. They are not too bad, they run about $25.
Glad to hear you are having 70 degree weather.
Phil
|
|
-
|
During work; new compressor, 7 cyl, not 5. New accumulator, new variable orifice, new lp switch.
Blew out condensor, and evap with denatured alcohol. Old orifice was destroyed during removal.
I did not look into the delay relay. Next round I will ohm the lp relay before I begin. Maybe bypass delay relay. Also will connect gauges. ( I have a high side port brazed to the line leaving the condensor.
Thanks
|
|
-
|
An extreme cold spell has halted my work. As soon as the thermometer rises a bit, I will tear into it again.
|
|
-
|
I bought a variable orifice at auto zone. That may have been a mistake.
|
|
-
|
hi david,
try jumping the connections to the low pressure switch to make it stay on.
the seven cylinder sanden is what i use, great compressor. note that it uses pag oil, not ester.
do you have manifold/ac gauges? look at the low pressure side, should say about 25-40 psi at idle. it's best to read low and high but i don't have a high-side port. need to borrow, rent, buy those gauges when you do the a/c work.
is your compressor aligned with the p/s pump and main pulley?
how did you clear the lines, did you use a air compressor? Best to use an a/c flush kit to clear the lines, but maybe denatured alcohol d was good enough, i don't know.
exactly right to put new o-rings and orifice tube (expansion valve)in.
i detached all the connections and flushed each one when i installed the sanden, except for the evaporator.
write back.
thanks,
byron golden
86 245
92 245
94 940
|
|
-
|
I have a service port in the high pressure line. As soon as I have a warm day I will connect gauges and try it again. If I jumper the lp switch, I suspect it will only pull it into a vacuum, but I will try it. It is acting like either a low charge, or a blockage. I cleared lines with denatured alcohol and nitrogen.
|
|
-
|
hi david,
that's great having a high side port.
a variable orifice would be a higher grade orifice tube, allowing better cooling at lower rpms.
jumping the switch is just a test to see if it gets cool by forcing the compressor to stay on and avoid rapid cycling.
from a ford bulletin board but applies to all a/c units:
" Did you have High side and Low side gauges on it if so what were the readings when it was on?
Cycling can be several things Low charge will cause the Low side to drop below 10psi and open the low side switch, Too much refrigerant or a blockage will cause the high side to get too high and the high side switch will open. Bottom you need both gauges to properly diagnose it . If you see frosted spot on one of the A/C lines there may be a blockage."
http://www.techsupportforum.com/forums/f155/ac-compressor-cycles-on-and-off-269985.html
forcing the compressor on, you might be able to qualify your problem by observing any icing on any of the lines.
i think you are very close to narrowing down your problem. you'll get it done.
regards,
byron golden
|
|
-
|
Hi,
You did not mention anything about oil. Did you add the amount to the compressor and an extra ounce for the accumulator?
Phil
|
|
-
|
New Sanden compressors come with oil in them. I added 2 oz. oil to system.
|
|
-
|
HI,
I would say you are finding out why I don't really care for the cheapness of these systems, let alone, their lack of fittings to save even more costs. The reduction of fittings started long ago. There are none on domestic refrigerators. They used the excuse to reduce leaks and tampering to do it.
My new to me 1993 has a very special factory one from what I can tell. It's all crap!
I'm sorry you are having trouble. I feel this is not your first rodeo doing this type of work.
I agree it does sound like you have a restriction. The high side gauge will tell what's happening along with the observance of the low side gauge to show flow.
I'm also concerned that Auto Zone computerized reference book does not take into account that you are converting to 134a and that the person punching the keys knows what to look for in the process.
If it does not have a flag on the orfice, if it gets noticed, you get a standard issue of "normally ordered with!"
I have also read about reducing the amount of 134a used to work across these coils.
Some how they, I don't know who, came up with this 80% less amount.
I do know for a fact that 134a operates with a 10% lack of efficiency to begin with when compared one pound to one pound of each.
Maybe it's because of the lesser amount and but nothing to do with its capability of moving X amounts of BTU's per pound of liquid. One or the other can or must be the cause the loss?
Water is our best refrigerant per pound. That is next to liquid hydrogen and it takes buckets of water to put out fires! Don't ask me which one in the water but H2O puts out a fire as the heat gets moved through evaporation.
It's is for the above reasons is why the size of the coils and fans. They had to be revised larger going into the nineties. There were already many complaints, to Volvo, that their systems using R12 were not comparable to our domestic cars in cooling. Now, They had to deal with the 10% loss to boot.
.
I worried about oil for those motorcycle sounds. I was not sure if it is shipped inside or outside the compressor due to which refrigerants used.
The sound might mean the compressor is just laboring.
At least you didn't lift the HP safety!
Two ounces of oil is "about" the right amount since you also cleaned out the tubing in both coils.
The desiccant bag is going to get coated with the most of it, once it all gets blowed all around.
Having or Adding too much oil causes headaches though.
It's worse on capillary tube or orifice systems as it interferes with charge balance that's based on volume of refrigerant changing sides.
Capillaries are really a fixed system device. Used to primarily be first "cheap" and it has fixed heat load exchange rate limitation. The Most common place you find these was in the home refrigerator due to the millions of units produced.
Unfortunately cars they have reached these proportions.
Unknown to most people, Refrigerators are made and sold into specific climates. There are tropics versions and another for colder climates.
They vary the charge by an ounce or so to compensate for drops in wattage efficiency because the two coils will rise higher due to the constant heat they operate in.
Today's high efficiency refrigerators come with warning about operating them in hot places like garages. They are flirting with smaller motors and tricks of using dampers. It's written in my latest refrigerator booklet, "Doing so can void warranties!"
I have wondered or curious of what's on the labels under the hoods of 90's Volvos sold at the equator. Even though A/C is considered a high temperature system, in that, it is Not food preservation critical. They make tropical radiators and fans, don't they?
IMHO, a variable orifice adds a "variable twist" to the charging aspects.
The gadget is "doing its on thing" based on a properly sized spring to slide the opening back and forth.
I have never used one and probably never would just on the fact there is no receiver to place excess liquid. I don't see the slight gain to be worth it's failure possibility.
Like you said, trash, it comes from lots of places and occurs in hose systems where in refrigerators with solid tubing, it does not. Their dryers are mounted solid in the line and refrigerators seldom move.
The desiccant is a wonderful source of trash as it is a beaded granulated powder that is getting vibrations from a car. I have found this grit all around an orifice's screen.
Who ever said the beads can it not wear down over time from the rapid flow of gas droplets. I see it being a torrent of rain in there.
Dryers used to be only in the high side. The inventors of refrigeration had reasons for that, besides having the moisture condensed in with a hot liquid. The idea is to stop it before going through the expansion device where it freezes.
I think you running a vacuum pump for 24 hrs is over kill, unless you didn't get below 29 inches mmHg. Time and heat is needed to good a job. You had the time going on for sure!
It is good that you are using a sight glass type charging cylinder. Wish I had one since I retired from company funded tools.
I have to use a homemade make shift recovery unit now. It's made of Ice buckets surrounding empty refrigerant bottles. I hate losing any my stash of R12.
It sight glass takes the guess work out of what's left in the hoses and that the true liquid weight went in. Once it's out in the line you "milk" the manifolds lines to move it all in except vapor of course.
They are ideal for these type of volume dependent systems, in fact, almost mandatory.
It's amazing for me to see into the automotive world with it left up to guess work without good specifications available. The word "proprietary" hurts everyone over greed.
These specifications come from the laboratories and on into journals and training manuals. At this day and age of our refrigeration world it's silly not to have the knowledge just out there!
It took a lot of us "old farts" to work through through these problems and make things work. It seems very sad to let people starve in two ways!
When you added the oil did you pour it straight into the accumulator inlet or add it by filling up a charging line?
If you put it all on the high side, by directly inside the compressoror or say directly into the condenser line or hose, it will take some time for it to clear the expansion device and balance out. Oil can lay in a low spot or at the beginning of end of turns and act like a restriction in either one of the coils.
That rapid pull down on the low side is the first indication of a restriction. A slow high side drop in pressure is the same. You may consider cycling the unit for a while to see if pressure equalize faster over some time before doing a refrigerant recovery.
Sure interested in what you discover either way!
Phil
|
|
-
|
Nearing the end of the story. I removed the $25.00 Auto Zone variable orifice, which had a tiny amount of grit in it. ( Not the problem ) Replaced it with a $3.00 standard orifice. AC now works like a charm. No motorcycle sounds. Blows 49 degree air after car cools down at 85 degree ambient. I am embarrassed to admit that I placed more confidence in a new non standard part than my knowledge of physics.
Lessons learned;
Always keep in mind new part does not mean working part.
I will not use a variable orifice again. They cost 8 times what the standard orifice costs, and the one I installed was factory defective. Probably not that much better than standard orifice. Keep it simple.
The American made Sanden 7 cylinder compressor is quiet as a mouse, and as I understand,an improvement over the stock 5 cylinder.
The conversion from R-12 to R-134 works just fine on a 1992.
Thanks for the help guys.
|
|
-
|
Thank you for your detailed response to my problem. I went back to Auto Zone and their computer system calls for the same orifice for 12 and 134! It looks like I have dirt in the system. ( I dont know how with all the alcohol I blew through the coils.) I am thinking of removing the variable orifice and putting a "stock" orifice back in. I expect to find trash in the variable orifice. If I dont, head scratching and cussing will result.
|
|
-
|
Hi,
Sorry! Again, I put in too much information you didn't need.
I edited my points from my other post.
It does not surprise me that one orifice could be the same for both.
The difference in BTU's per pound is not that much but the pressures are. It takes more energy to compress 134a to get the same cooling per trip of circulation.
IMHO, a variable orifice adds a "variable twist" to the charging aspects.
The gadget is "doing its on thing" based on a properly sized spring to slide the opening back and forth with slight pressure changes between sides.
It's like playing with the torque band of an engine with different cams. The engine does it "job" at the low end or the higher end of rpm.
I have never used one and probably never would just on the fact there is no receiver to place excess liquid when demand is low if you happen to be overcharged?
I don't see the slight gain to be worth it's failure possibility.
When you added the oil, did you pour it straight into the accumulator inlet or added into the compressor case?
If you put it all on the high side, by directly inside the compressoror or say directly into the condenser line or hose, it will take some time for it to clear the expansion device and balance out.
Oil can lay in a low spot or at the beginning of end of turns and act like a restriction in either one of the coils.
A very rapid pull down on the low side is the first indication of a restriction.
The next is frost or sweating appearing ahead of the expansion device or a little ways away or down from the expansion device.
A rapid high side rise or a slow high side drop in pressure is the same meaning, a restriction.
A condenser does not heat up as rapidly so the pressure moving up is moderately slower under normal conditions.
Watching the temperature dial portion on your gage set will tell you a lot.
Until the condenser get closer to hot 30 to 40 degrees above the outside ambient temperature is normal.
If it goes to a higher temperatures before running very long it means a restriction.
The evaporator goes down in pressure but stabilizes in its intended zone and holds there under normal operation.
Excessive lower pressure right away means a restriction.
If you see very low numbers of temperature or pressure (as they are close) the restriction is starving the evaporator and the vent air will not chill quickily.
You may or have to consider cycling the unit several times, for while, to see if pressure equalizes faster with each cycle.
Do this over some time, be patient, before doing a refrigerant recovery.
Oil will be slow to get crossed over and pass itself around through a expansion device.
Phil
|
|
-
|
How many ozs. of 134 did you put in?
|
|
-
|
The label by the radiator calls for 2.07 lbs. of R-12 for a B230 engine. I initially charged the system with 2.07 x 80% = 1.6 lbs. or 22 oz. The car would quickly go into low pressure cutout. I added 4 oz. more, which resulted in the current condition. I used an old style charging cylinder to measure the charge. The low pressure cut out is what is baffling. I wonder if Auto zone gave me the wrong variable orifice, or if there is trash in the system. I feel I really flushed the system well. I am considering removing the variable orifice and installing the regular orifice.
|
|
-
|
With that new compressor, I guess you have no access for a high side gauge, but the clog you suspect was my first thought reading your post.
I'm a veteran of a failed R134a conversion of a 240, though different in two ways: It was a pre-CCOT system (TXV) in 1990. And I suspect you will fix yours; I never did, after the compressor locked up -- just put a JY unit in for the power steering idler. I underestimated my daughter's value of working AC. She soon bought another 240 and had the dealership service it.
--
Art Benstein near Baltimore
Two vultures board an airplane, each carrying two dead raccoons. The stewardess looks at them and says: "I'm sorry, gentlemen, only one carrion allowed per passenger."
|
|
-
|
I do have high side access. There is a schraeder fitting brazed on. I am suspecting a wrong expansion device, or trash in the exp. device.
|
|
|
|
|